It is absolutely wonderful. To be honest, I bought it for the packaging, but the product itself is amazing. It comes with an extra brush, and even though the feather-like aplicator might look weird, it's actually very convenient to use. It does not smudge and it lasts all day. Also, it's not hard to remove if you use an oil-based cleanser. It's the only liner that I can use on the upper waterline, without pocking my eyes! I will definitely repurchase it in the near future.